| Standards of judgment |
QUATS |
PHENOLS |
ALDEHYDE |
HALOGENS |
SILVER BREEZE |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
| Activity field |
Bacteria gram. + |
Bacteria gram. + |
Bacteria gram. + |
Bacteria gram. + |
Bacteria gram. + |
| |
Mycosis, Yeast, Algae |
Bacteria gram. - |
Bacteria gram. - |
Bacteria gram. - |
Bacteria gram. - |
| |
Herpes |
Mycosis, Yeast, |
Mycosis, Yeast, Spores |
Mycosis, Yeast, |
Mycosis, Yeast, |
| |
Virus b |
Virus b |
Virus b/u |
Virus b/u |
Spores Virus b/u, |
| |
|
|
unsheated |
unsheated |
Ameba |
| |
|
|
|
|
Protozoa |
| Efficiency gaps |
Bacteria gram. -, |
Anthrax, virus unsheated, |
Ameba, Protozoa |
Ameba, Protozoa, |
___ |
| |
Myco-bacteria, Spores, |
Ameba, Biofilms |
Biofilms |
Biofilms |
|
| |
Virus unsheated, Ameba, |
|
|
|
|
| |
Protozoa, Biofilms |
|
|
|
|
| pH optimum |
5 - 9 |
2 - 8 |
4 - 9 |
5 - 9 |
2 - 8 |
| pH Stability |
1- 12 |
1 - 14 |
3 - 12 |
1 - 9 |
2 - 8 |
| Albumine torbidity and foam |
considerable |
not utilized |
not utilized |
considerable |
none |
| deterioration in contact |
|
modification of |
modification of |
|
|
| with beer |
|
color/taste |
color/taste |
|
|
| Hard Water Compatibility |
bad |
very good |
good |
good |
very good |
| Albumine capacity |
bad |
very good |
bad |
bad |
good |
| Dirtiness capacity |
bad |
very good |
unsatisfied |
good |
passable |
| Behavior on surfaces |
Residues on |
Absorption on rubber |
high dump pressure, |
Residues on |
very good |
| |
surfaces |
and plastic material |
air burden in rooms |
surfaces |
|
| Smell |
inodorous |
intense |
pungent |
intense |
inodorous |
| Behavior on foam |
very foaming |
see albumine torbidity |
see albumine torbidity |
good |
very good |
| Skin compatibility |
good |
good in relation to the |
danger of sensitization |
skin and eye irritation |
very good |
| |
|
applicated concentration |
skin and eye irritation |
toxic gases |
|
| Carcinomatous |
no |
yes, demonstrable |
yes, demonstrable |
yes, formally |
no |
| |
|
|
|
Chloroform |
|
| (ADI) Acc. Daily Intake |
0.20mg/kg |
|
|
|
0.20 mg/kg |
| Mutagenicity |
no |
till 800 mg/kg no |
yes |
yes, formally |
no |
| |
|
|
|
Chloroform |
|
| LD50 oral on rat |
350 - 900 mg/l |
1'830 - 3'000 mg/l |
800 - 1'700 mg/l |
|
over 2'000 mg/l |
| Water compromising |
3 |
1 - 2 |
1 - 2 |
2 - 3 |
0 |
| WGK Germany |
|
|
|
|
|
| General stability diluted |
at short term only |
at short term only |
at short term only |
at short time only |
very good |
| Temperature stability |
passable |
bad |
bad |
very bad |
very good |
| Corrosion depending on |
|
|
|
high |
none |
| the applicable temperature |
|
|
|
|
|
| Bio Improvement on |
90% after 5 days |
100% after 3-7 days |
good, |
very bad |
100% after 2-4 h |
| clarification plants |
|
neutralization |
neutralization |
neutralization |
|
| |
|
needed |
needed |
needed |
|
| Bio Improvement on |
65-70% |
80-90% |
75-90% |
|
100% |
| "Closed bottle Test" |
within 20 days |
within 20 days |
within 5-10 days |
|
within 24 h |
| OECD 301 D |
|
|
|
|
|
| Universal Use |
restricted |
restricted |
restricted |
passable |
very good |
| Measurement of concentration |
impossible |
impossible |
impossible |
very good |
very good |
| on spot |
|
|
|
|
|
| Fully automatic dosage |
impossible |
impossible |
impossible |
very good |
very good |
|